Addressing the risks in crypto: laying out the options
• The recent high-profile failures of FTX and other crypto firms have re-ignited the debate on the
appropriate policy response to address the risks in crypto, including through regulation.
• The “shadow financial” functions enabled by crypto markets share many of the vulnerabilities
of traditional finance. These risks are exacerbated by specific features of crypto.
• Authorities may consider different – not mutually exclusive – lines of action to tackle the risks
in crypto. These include containment or regulation of the crypto sector or an outright ban.
• Central banks and public authorities could also work to make TradFi more attractive. A key
option is to encourage sound innovation with central bank digital currencies (CBDCs).
After the failure of several major crypto firms, addressing the risks from crypto markets has become a
more pressing policy issue. Cryptoasset markets have gone through booms and busts before, and so far,
the busts have not led to wider contagion threatening financial stability. Yet the scale and prominence of
recent failures heighten the urgency of addressing these risks before crypto markets become systemic.
The crypto ecosystem and the “shadow financial” functions it engages in, through centralised financial
entities (CeFi) and decentralised finance (DeFi) protocols, share many of the vulnerabilities that are familiar
from traditional finance (TradFi). But several factors exacerbate the standard risks. These relate to high
leverage, liquidity and maturity mismatches and substantial information asymmetries. Policy responses
should consider how to address these sources of risk appropriately, given the borderless nature of crypto.
This bulletin briefly summarises the lessons of the 2022 turmoil. It then outlines three – non-mutually
exclusive – lines of action to address the risks in crypto: a ban, containment and regulation, as well as their
pros and cons. It also outlines complementary lines of policy action to address inefficiencies in TradFi and
curb the demand for crypto. One key option would be to encourage sound innovation with CBDCs. An
online appendix gives a selective overview of ongoing initiatives in crypto regulation.
The recent crypto turmoil: features and lessons
After peaking in late 2021, when cryptoasset prices, stablecoin volumes and DeFi activity reached all-time
highs (Graph 1, left-hand panel), the crypto ecosystem faced turmoil in 2022. The decline started early in
the year, but problems became acute in May. It was then that a large stablecoin, TerraUSD (UST) – which
relied on an algorithm to maintain its peg to the US dollar – collapsed, causing contagion in crypto markets
(Graph 1, centre panel). A period of relative calm followed, but crypto markets again saw serious stress in
November 2022, when the FTX crypto trading platform declared bankruptcy. In the past, despite repeated
turmoil, the crypto ecosystem has survived and prices have often recovered (Graph 1, right-hand panel).
There are thus reasons to doubt that crypto will fade away on its own. In particular, a substantial part of
the crypto community firmly believes in the ideological pursuit of a decentralised system as an alternative
Matteo.Aquilina
Jon.Frost
Andreas Schrimpf
Andreas.Schrimpf@bis.org